"Im excited about anything that can help us reduce infections." said Dr. Monica Ruiz, a NIAID behavioral scientist who is helping conduct the study. "If this is another tool we can put into our toolbox, that would be fantastic."
But all sides also cautioned that the study was preliminary, and there are no guarantees the drugs will work well in people. "Monkeys are not little humans." Paxton said.
Even in a best-case scenario, no one believes the drug will be 100 percent effective. For that reason, it would be combined with counseling, condom distribution and other methods that currently reduce the spread of HIV.
"This will never be regarded by us as a stand-alone intervention." said Paxton.
A major fear is that the drug will make people feel safer engaging in risky behavior than they otherwise would have. "I would be concerned if [the drug] was to be available broadly." said Dr. Philippe Chiliade, the medical director for the Whitman-Walker Clinic in Washington D.C., which is unaffiliated with the study. "We could end up with the HIV epidemic being fueled even more than it is now."
Also of concern is that some doctors have already begun prescribing Truvada—which was approved only for HIV treatment—to HIV-negative people who engage in extremely risky behaviors. Another small segment of the high-risk population is taking the drug illegally without a prescription.
"If people start using this, they could be putting themselves at high risk." Paxton said.